Stay & Play


Blue Door Cottages

Blue Door Cottages is a collection of vacation rental cabins located on Lake Shafer in Monticello, Indiana. In addition to enjoying the lakefront lifestyle, we are also just minutes to Indiana Beach Amusement Park. With a pool, boat docks, playground and fire pits, we have something for everyone to enjoy. This is the place to make your best family vacation memories year after year.

Phone: 574-870-2744
Address: 5312 N West Shafer Dr, Monticello IN 47960

Best Western Brandywine

304 S 6th Street Monticello, Indiana 47960
Website: Click Here
Lighthouse Lodge

304 S 6th Street Monticello, Indiana 47960


A Lake Shafer lodging option, Blue Door Cottages has a collection of vacation rental cabins located just minutes from Indiana Beach Amusement Park. Complete with a pool, lakefront amenities, boat docks, playground and firepits, Blue Door is clean and family-oriented…a place where people return annually to visit.

Monticello’s most luxurious bed & breakfast on scenic Lake Shafer, the Lighthouse Lodge is open all year long and ready to host your next getaway or extended stay!

Alexander’s Landing features 9 units, an indoor pool, hot tub, grilling area, boat docks, and is within walking distance to Indiana Beach Amusement Park.


Monticello offers a wide range of activities all centered around the beauty of its surrounding lakes. Lake lovers can bounce between Lake Shafer and Lake Freeman. On Lake Shafer you will find attractions such as Indiana Beach and boat rental opportunities. On Lake Freeman you can experience the Madam Carroll, which offers 2 to 3-hour cruise excursions. On both lakes, visitors can enjoy the atmosphere of live music, scenic beauty, and fellowship.


The greater Monticello area offers a variety of dining options. Some of our destination dining experiences are focused on a lakeside view. Sportsman, Oakdale, Oak & Barrel, Riverside, Skyroom, and many more! Monticello also offers golfers a unique dining experience to wind down after a game. Visitors will find two breweries; Kopacetic Beer Factory and Crasian Brewing Company as well as two wineries; Whyte Horse Winery and Fruitshine Wine to enjoy.

Follow Us

Quick Links

Call Us